Each UPSC Civil Services Examination (CSE) cycle brings with it new trends and performance benchmarks. A close comparison of the paper-wise scores of toppers from 2023 and 2024 reveals subtle shifts in scoring patterns, evaluation strictness, and performance strategies. For aspirants aiming at future attempts, understanding these insights can make the difference between good and great.
Overview: Scoring Trends and General Observations
One of the starkest differences between the two years lies in the overall score levels: 2023 was a more scoring year at the top. All top five rankers crossed the 1045-mark, with AIR 1 scoring 1099. In contrast, 2024’s top five ranks hovered between 1032 and 1043, indicating possibly tougher papers or stricter evaluation. A ~5% margin between the 2023 and 2024 toppers suggests that in 2023, consistency across all papers played a bigger role, whereas in 2024, candidates often relied on strategic excellence in specific sections to break into the top ranks.
Essay Paper: A Game of Extremes
In 2024, the Essay paper became a field of extremes. The highest scorer touched 144, while the lowest among the top 5 had just 100. In contrast, 2023 essay scores were uniformly strong, though no one hit the 140s.
| Rank | 2023 Essay | 2024 Essay |
|---|---|---|
| AIR 1 | 117 | 100 |
| AIR 2 | 133 | 144 |
| AIR 3 | 136 | 103 |
| AIR 4 | 129 | 109 |
| AIR 5 | 130 | 118 |
Key Insight: An outstanding essay can catapult a candidate to the top, but average performance here can be offset by excellence elsewhere — especially in GS or Optional.
General Studies Performance: Paper-wise Breakdown
GS1 (History, Art & Culture, Geography, Society)
2023 toppers had a slight edge overall, but 2024’s AIR 1 scored the highest in this paper.
| Rank | 2023 GS1 | 2024 GS1 |
|---|---|---|
| AIR 1 | 104 | 112 |
| AIR 2 | 109 | 102 |
| AIR 3 | 109 | 90 |
| AIR 4 | 83 | 89 |
| AIR 5 | 110 | 101 |
Trend: GS1 continues to be moderate in returns — useful but not always high-yield.
GS2 (Polity, Governance, IR)
Both years were strong, but 2023 produced the highest individual scores (up to 132). GS2 remains a stable and rewarding paper with proper command.
| Rank | 2023 GS2 | 2024 GS2 |
|---|---|---|
| AIR 1 | 132 | 125 |
| AIR 2 | 127 | 121 |
| AIR 3 | 121 | 123 |
| AIR 4 | 119 | 117 |
| AIR 5 | 115 | 113 |
GS3 (Economy, S&T, Environment, Security)
This paper typically yields lower marks. Both years confirmed this trend, with exceptions — one 2023 topper scored 120.
| Rank | 2023 GS3 | 2024 GS3 |
|---|---|---|
| AIR 1 | 95 | 86 |
| AIR 2 | 103 | 90 |
| AIR 3 | 98 | 108 |
| AIR 4 | 90 | 91 |
| AIR 5 | 120 | 107 |
Tip: GS3 is time-consuming and unpredictable. Focus on efficiency and basics.
GS4 (Ethics & Integrity)
Ethics remains a high-ROI paper. Top scorers in both years crossed the 125-mark, with 2023’s AIR 1 scoring a stellar 143.
| Rank | 2023 GS4 | 2024 GS4 |
|---|---|---|
| AIR 1 | 143 | 141 |
| AIR 2 | 134 | 125 |
| AIR 3 | 136 | 126 |
| AIR 4 | 127 | 128 |
| AIR 5 | 114 | 124 |
Advice: Ethics offers consistency. A well-structured, thoughtful paper can pay off.
Optional Subjects: The Rank Maker
Optional papers continue to be the biggest differentiators. Candidates in both years cracked 150+ in at least one optional paper — an achievement that often determines the final rank.
| Rank | 2023 Optional-2 | 2024 Optional-2 |
|---|---|---|
| AIR 1 | 160 (Elec. Engg.) | 147 (PSIR) |
| AIR 2 | 153 (Sociology) | 152 (PSIR) |
| AIR 3 | 137 (Anthro) | 156 (Philosophy) |
| AIR 4 | 157 (Anthro) | 121 (Sociology) |
| AIR 5 | 147 (Economics) | 137 (Sociology) |
Strategy: If one paper underperforms, the second can make up — but ideally, aim for balanced strength in both.
Interview/Personality Test: The Final Push
Interview marks can pull up your rank dramatically. 2024’s AIR 4 (Margi Chirag) had the highest interview score: 210, a major reason for her top 5 placement.
| Rank | 2023 Interview | 2024 Interview |
|---|---|---|
| AIR 1 | 200 | 200 |
| AIR 2 | 175 | 187 |
| AIR 3 | 190 | 190 |
| AIR 4 | 185 | 210 |
| AIR 5 | 193 | 201 |
Lesson: Personality Test isn't just formality — it's a rank booster, especially with scores above 190.
ROI Summary: Which Papers Matter Most?
| Paper | Avg Marks | Max Marks | ROI Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| GS4 (Ethics) | ~115+ | 143 | High ROI (must-score) |
| Optional (2) | ~280–320 | 330+ | Decisive (Top Rank Maker) |
| Essay | ~105–115 | 144 | Volatile but high impact |
| GS2 (Polity) | ~110 | 132 | Stable & worth investing |
| GS1 | ~95–100 | 112 | Moderate, unpredictable |
| GS3 | ~90 | 108–120 | Low ROI (balance time) |
| Interview | ~190 | 210 | Rank booster (soft skill) |
Final Advice for Aspirants
- Power Trio = GS4 + Optional + Interview
- Aim for 100+ in Essay and 110+ in GS2
- Don’t bleed marks in GS3 — maintain basics
- Build answer-writing stamina from Day 1
- Revise in cycles; don’t get trapped in content overload
- Master your optional — it’s your strategic edge
- Prepare for the interview well in advance — confidence counts
Whether you’re targeting 2025 or beyond, this analysis shows one thing clearly: UPSC success is multidimensional. It's not about excelling in every single paper, but about strategic strength and balanced high performance. Take cues from both years — consistency from 2023, and smart scoring from 2024 — and you’ll be on the right path.
Join Margdarshan IAS Assessment & Guidance Programme 2026
Want to crack UPSC with evidence-based strategy? If they can then you will! Join us where we decode the examiner’s mindset using past topper data, GS-paper trends, and optional subject ROI. Stop guessing, start strategizing. Every test, every feedback is designed to push you closer to your name in the final list. Join now and study smart.